When sixteen-year-old Chelsea Martin's future stepmother gives her a total makeover, she attracts all of the wrong boys and drives away many girls, but her friend Janelle keeps telling Chelsea to be true to herself, while helping her find a way to catch the eye of Nicholas, the one "non-jerk" at school.

Sixteen-year-old Elise thinks starting her new high school knowing popular Asher will make things easier, but not only does she develop a crush on him, she gets on the wrong side of his girlfriend and finds herself accused of "sexting."